Topic on User talk:Da1n0nly0mega

From Wikizilla, the kaiju encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search

Shusuke Kaneko

17
Summary by Da1n0nly0mega

im not sure if this is actually going anywhere.

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

Would you at least state the reason to revert? I saw these opinions on Twitter and decided to add here. If you need links to the tweet, I will show you.

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

What do you mean that "an opinion isn't a fact" ? If your logic applies, many trivia on many other articles must be deleted.

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

In this case, Kaneko himself acknowledges similarities between his films and Monsterverse films. So, what's wrong with my latest edit?

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

Please reply. I would like to add and hide it for now, and then leave it to admins. If admins decide to delete it, I have no objection to it.

Astounding Beyond Belief (talkcontribs)

While there are a lot of interesting parallels between Kaneko's films and the Monsterverse, I don't think this one is especially notable.

Da1n0nly0mega (talkcontribs)

Minus one goji has elbow spikes too, i don't think opinions are cited on pages as info.

Astounding Beyond Belief (talkcontribs)

We don't need to cite anything to point out parallels between works, but what's a notable parallel is eternally up for debate.

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

Folks, thanks for replying. Well, as I said I noticed this pointing out on SNS and I did not "make it up". For example, more than 200 people agreed with "Gamera" in this Reddit thread. So what should I do in this case? https://www.reddit.com/r/GODZILLA/comments/18vwrw3/whats_your_opinion_in_the_fact_that_spikes_on_the/ https://twitter.com/TheGumGun/status/1728991976081743950 https://twitter.com/0KenShikishima0/status/1733580975588708487 https://twitter.com/SPOOKKTOBR/status/1733547949198586327 https://twitter.com/DBanes2/status/1733638110972608758 https://twitter.com/PenisShits/status/1733580357671223301

Da1n0nly0mega (talkcontribs)

i don't think random internet user opinions factor into what goes on a page?

especially since he isn't even the first Godzilla to feature elbow or arm spikes

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

My point is, the number of people agreeing with this is "not small" (not big either, I'm not sure how many people would agree if there is a big poll). If this was noted and supported only by a few people, I would not bring up this matter on Wikizilla in the first place.

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

Da1n0nly0mega, how about I add the trivia and hide it for now?

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

No reply. So I take it as a "yes", ok?

Da1n0nly0mega (talkcontribs)

Astounding said it's not noteworthy,


And again Minus One Godzilla also has elbow spikes, if anything that makes evolved Godzilla bear more similarities to MinusGoji than anything Gamera related especially since both films have come out in the same timeframe, aside from that "elbow spikes" are not even a unique design element Gamera came up with first as Gomora from Ultraman which predates the Heisei trilogy by decades has them.

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

Astounding also said "what's a notable parallel is eternally up for debate".

And again, I didn't make this up and more than 200 people on Reddit, dozens other on Twitter agree with this parallel.

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

That's why I suggested to hide it as a compromise.

Ultraman rides a dragon cuz yes (talkcontribs)

ABB already said it's not noteworhty, you just have to calm down and accept that this is not going ur way.

DreamBrisdin (talkcontribs)

Why did you close the talk? It's not settled yet. I don't want to engage in edit warring, so would you please agree with the compromise that I add and hide it for now?